In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of two outdoor fire features: a fire pit or chiminea which is better that is the question? While both can provide a beautiful, and cozy addition to your outdoor living space, there are some key differences that you should be considered before you decide which one is right for you, we’ll examine five key pros and cons of each, to help you make an informed decision.

Read on to discover which one is the better choice for you, and what you should look for in each type of fire feature, by the end of this article, you’ll know exactly which fire feature is the best fit for your lifestyle.

Prairie Fire Chiminea

Rust-free Cast Aluminum Chiminea for your deck or patio, with grill plates for cooking.

Fire pits and chimineas have become increasingly popular outdoor heating and entertaining options, both providing warmth and ambiance, as well as a place to gather around with friends and family.

In this article, we’ll compare fire pits and chimineas, discussing their pros and cons so you can decide which one is best for you and your family so let’s get started.

What is a Firepit?

A metal fire pit is a type of outdoor fireplace or fire pit that is made from metal materials such as steel, stainless steel, or cast iron, metal fire pits come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and designs, including bowls, boxes, and designs with decorative cutouts, they are popular for their durability, low maintenance, and resistance to weather and wear.

A metal fire pit can be fueled by wood, charcoal, or propane and provide a convenient and easy way to enjoy an outdoor fire, they are often used for entertainment and relaxation, as well as for cooking or roasting marshmallows.

Most metal fire pits like the Solo Stove are portable, making them easy to move and place in different locations in your outdoor living space.

The Solo Stove and the TIKI fire pits are also considered to be smokeless making them a great choice and it really helps if you have neighbors close by allowing you to control annoying smoke.

Pros of Firepits

Whether you want to buy a metal fire pit or build a brick one in your backyard, you will be guaranteed endless summer fun, just remember that firepits do have pros and cons, so go ahead and look at them to help you decide what is the best option for you.


A metal fire pit is known for its durability and long-lasting performance, they are made of materials that in most cases are resistant to heat, corrosion, and rust, ensuring that they can withstand the elements and continue to look great for years to come.

And most metal stainless steel firepits can be left outside during the winter, although it’s always best to cover your firepit or put it away if possible.

The nice thing about a metal fire pit is that if it does start to corrode or you would like to freshen it up, you can paint yours with high-temperature wood stove paint if yours is rusting click here to buy some.


Metal firepits come in a wide range of styles, shapes, and sizes, making them suitable for a variety of outdoor spaces and settings, from contemporary designs to traditional styles, there is a metal firepit to match any outdoor decor.

TIKI Brand Smokeless Firepit

One of the best smokeless firepits on the market from a trusted brand, this firepit comes with an easy-to-clean bottom drawer.

Easy to Clean

Unlike stone or masonry firepits, a metal fire pit is easy to clean and maintain, simply wipe them down with a damp cloth and they are good as new.

Some firepits will even have an ash drawer to make it easier to clean out any residue from your last backyard fire.

If you decide to buy a stainless steel fire pit then you can even polish it and bring it back to its original shine, this can be done with a simple metal polish and a rag.


Many metal firepits are designed to be portable, making them easy to move from one location to another, whether you want to use your firepit on your deck, patio, or in your backyard, you can easily take it with you.

Some firepits will come with a carry bag, and this is particularly useful because the newest craze is to take a firepit to a tailgate party.


Compared to stone or masonry firepits, metal firepits are often more affordable and budget-friendly, normally costing anywhere from $150 to $1000, but most portable ones will cost around $300.

They are a great option for those who want to enjoy the ambiance and warmth of a firepit without breaking the bank, and over time they will give you more enjoyment than any price or cost.

Cons of Firepits

There are also some negative things that are important to consider when buying a metal fire pit, some of those can be how hot a firepit can get around the edges. or maybe you are asking to do metal firepits rust. or do cast iron firepits rust? do they warp? or maybe are there enough style options to suit my needs?

In this next section let’s deal with all of those questions, starting with firepit heat conductivity.

Heat Conductivity

Metal is a good conductor of heat, which means that metal firepits can get hot to the touch during use, this can be a safety hazard, especially for small children and pets.


Although most metal firepits are resistant to rust, they are not immune to it, over time, exposure to moisture and other elements can cause a metal fire pit to rust, affecting its appearance and performance.

If this happens to yours over time you can always paint it, if needed.


High heat levels can cause metal firepits to warp, especially if they are not made from high-quality materials, and this is normal, because if a fireplace firebox can warp with heat why wouldn’t a firepit too?

The problem is this can lead to cracks and other damage that can compromise the integrity of the firepit.


When metal firepits are in use, they can produce a loud, crackling sound that can be disruptive to outdoor gatherings, this can be especially problematic for those who live in close proximity to neighbors.

Limited Style Options

While there is a wide range of metal firepit styles to choose from, some people may find that the options are limited compared to stone or masonry firepits, which can make it difficult to find a firepit that perfectly matches your style and decor.

If you are looking for some different styles, Sunnydaze Decor is a great place to look.

What is a Chiminea?

A chiminea is a type of outdoor fireplace or fire pit that originated in Mexico and is typically made of clay or metal, It is cylindrical in shape and has a large opening at the front and a chimney-like stack at the top, which helps to release smoke and ash.

Chimineas are often used for outdoor heating and cooking, as well as for decoration and ambiance. They are popular for their unique, rustic style and are typically fueled by wood or charcoal.

Chimineas are available in a variety of sizes and designs, making them a versatile option for any outdoor living space.


Chimineas are typically made from the materials stated below:

  • Clay terracotta chiminea
  • Cast aluminum chiminea
  • Metal chiminea (steel)
  • cast iron chiminea
  • Stainless steel chiminea
  • Copper chiminea

Pros of Chimineas

Some of the great pros that you get from chimineas are there are many different styles and textures, they can become a beautiful centerpiece in your yard, and they are fuel-efficient among other things, let’s take a look at those now.

Style and Aesthetics

Chimineas are known for their unique, rustic style and can be an attractive addition to any outdoor space, coming in a variety of designs, including traditional clay and modern metal styles, this makes it easy so you can find one that complements your decor.

The original clay terracotta chiminea is the most popular style for a backyard garden because of its earthy texture.

Steel and cast aluminum chiminea have become backyard favorites because of their modern look and style, being able to form them into different modern shapes makes them appealing to many.


Chimineas create a warm and inviting atmosphere, making them ideal for entertaining friends and family or just relaxing on your own.

They are also great for roasting marshmallows or cooking food over the fire, many of the modern ones come with grill sets to BBQ or cook on, and who doesn’t want that when you have friends and family over?


Chimineas can be used in many outdoor settings, making them a versatile choice for any home, you can place one on your patio, deck, or in your backyard garden.

For decks, you will need a fireproof mat that can catch any embers that could fall out.

In a backyard, Garden place it between some plants for a nice calm atmosphere, just be careful about placing it under trees because at times sparks can come up and out of the chimney.

Fuel Efficiency

Chimineas are relatively fuel-efficient compared to other types of open fire pits, and it’s because they require less wood or charcoal to maintain a fire, which can save you money on fuel costs in the long run.

Note: If a clay Chiminea is heated too fast or you start a roaring fire in it too quickly it may crack because of the thermal shock, this can also be true with a cast iron chiminea, because of its hard metal.

So always start a small fire for at least the first 15min, just some kindling if possible then add larger pieces of firewood as you like, once it is hot you should have no problem.

If you follow these steps you won’t be saying “My chiminea cracked first use

Jonathan A.


Chimineas are an eco-friendly option for outdoor heating, as they emit fewer pollutants and particulates into the air compared to traditional wood-burning fireplaces or fire pits. Additionally, they do not produce as much ash or smoke, which reduces their impact on the environment.

Chimineas have a closed-off design which helps to contain and draw the smoke away, that way the smoke in not where you are sitting and perfect for backyards with close neighbors.

Cons of Chimineas

Like all things, nothing is perfect, so below are some of the cans of buying a chiminea for your yard or patio, but don’t be deterred, none of them are game changers.

Limited Heat Output

Chimineas are typically made of clay or metal and are not as efficient in radiating heat compared to other types of fire pits, this means that they may not provide enough warmth for larger groups or for outdoor spaces that are especially cold.

If you are looking for a chiminea that will radiate heat I suggest buying a cast iron chiminea, you can even find some antique cast iron chimineas online for a good price and it will be very original.


Chimineas require regular maintenance to keep them in good condition, including cleaning and resealing, the clay terracotta chiminea can also be susceptible to cracking or chipping, which can weaken its structural integrity and make them unsafe to use, that’s the nature of the beast.

If this happens you can easily buy a clay chiminea crack repair kit and problem solved.

Safety Concerns

Chimineas can pose safety hazards if they are not used properly, for example, if they are placed too close to flammable materials like trees or a wall for example, they can start a fire, and if they tip over, they can cause burns or start a fire, so deciding where you will put it in your yard is important.


Chimineas are not as portable as other types of fire pits, making them difficult to move from one location to another for some this can be a drawback if you want to use your fire pit in different areas of your property or take it with you on trips.


Chimineas can be more expensive than other types of fire pits, especially if you opt for a higher-end model made of materials like cast iron or stainless steel, A chiminea may not be a cost-effective option for those on a tight budget.

So Fire Pit or Chiminea Which is Better?

When it comes to selecting the best outdoor heating option, a fire pit or chiminea both have their advantages and disadvantages, fire pits are versatile, and can be used both to provide heat and to create an inviting atmosphere for family and friends and in most cases you can sit around them, making them a great family option.

They can also be used to cook food and provide a great source of entertainment, on the other hand, clay chimineas are also great for providing warmth and atmosphere they also come in a variety of styles and shapes, whether you are looking for clay chiminea or cast iron chiminea they are both excellent addition for any backyard.


In conclusion, the choice between a fire pit and a chiminea comes down to personal preference. Both have their pros and cons that should be considered when making a selection.

Fire pits are great for larger gatherings and for providing more heat, but they do require more space.

Chimineas can be placed in smaller spaces, but they provide less heat and may not be suitable for larger events, ultimately, it is up to you to decide what will best suit your needs.

Thank you for reading, please leave a comment or share with the buttons on the side or bottom of your screen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share to...